What Makes a Good Decodable Book? 5 Things to Look For
With so many decodable books on the market, educators should follow these 5 criteria to select the best options for their school.
Decodable books have been used as part of early literacy instruction for decades. They provide students with valuable opportunities to practice new phonics skills and build on previous knowledge. But not all decodable books are created equal!
Historically, decodable books were known for their silly, nonsensical stories—think: The pig jigs in a wig. Due to the limitations of writing such tightly controlled text, decodable books are often boring or use awkward or strange language structures. These kinds of decodables can be challenging for novice readers, especially English language learners.
The good news is that renewed interest in phonics instruction has led to much higher-quality decodable books on the market. When selecting decodable books to add to your school, classroom, or home library, consider these criteria:
-
What makes a book truly decodable?
A book is decodable if it matches what students have already been taught. Decodable books are designed to reinforce and provide meaningful practice with previously taught skills—not introduce new phonics concepts. This repeated application helps students build accurate, automatic word recognition, fluency, and confidence as they become proficient readers.
DEFINITION
Decodable books are designed to reinforce and provide meaningful practice with previously taught skills—not introduce new phonics concepts.
-
Engaging Storylines
High-quality decodable books should offer more than phonics practice; they should also provide stories and information that students genuinely want to read. In fiction, look for books with memorable characters, a meaningful plot, and a satisfying beginning, middle, and end. In nonfiction, the information should be accurate, engaging, and presented in a way that sparks curiosity and builds knowledge.
-
Natural Language Structure
The language should sound natural and authentic. Decodable books should reflect the way language is naturally spoken and written while reinforcing previously taught phonics skills. Read the text aloud. If it sounds awkward or overly repetitive, it may not provide the best reading experience for students. High-quality decodable books strike a balance between controlled text and engaging, natural-sounding language, giving students meaningful opportunities to apply their decoding skills while enjoying the reading experience.
-
Captivating Illustrations and Photographs
High-quality illustrations and photographs help make reading engaging and enjoyable. While the primary purpose of decodable books is to provide practice with previously taught phonics skills, students also deserve books that are visually appealing and age appropriate. Look for books with vibrant artwork or photographs, diverse characters, and engaging content that motivates students to keep reading. The illustrations and photographs should support comprehension and engagement as students learn to rely on the print for decoding.
-
Systematic Learning Opportunities
The best decodable books provide opportunities to practice newly taught skills while reinforcing previously learned ones. Look for book collections that build systematically, incorporating cumulative review of phonics patterns and high-frequency words. This thoughtful progression gives students repeated opportunities to apply their learning, strengthening decoding skills and building confidence with every book.
Want a more in-depth explanation? Watch Session 1 of our free three-part webinar series, Foundations That Inspire. Our literacy specialists walk through: why quality decodable books matter, what makes a quality decodable book, how to calculate decodability, and how to align decodable books with a systematic scope and sequence. Our specialists also share high-impact routines for building fluency.
Watch the recording of Session 1: Unlock the Code—Using Decodable Books to Strengthen Phonics Skills
By following these tips, you’ll be able to select dynamic decodable books to use when teaching students how to read—and cultivate a love of reading at the same time!
Looking to build out your decodable library? Look no further than Pioneer Valley Books!
Discover beautifully designed decodable books that do more than teach phonics—they inspire confidence, curiosity, and joyful reading. Whether you’re building foundational skills or exploring fascinating nonfiction topics, our collections—MyCodables, Phonics Storybooks, and InfoCodables—provide engaging, systematic support every step of the way.
Go deeper with our free webinar series: Foundations That Inspire: A Three-Part Webinar Series on Unlocking the Full Power of Decodable Books
In our engaging and practical three-part webinar series, our literacy specialists go beyond how to choose decodable books and show you how they can build confident, joyful, and capable readers and writers. Whether you’re a classroom teacher, literacy coach, or curriculum leader, this series offers evidence-aligned strategies to help you make the most of decodable texts across your instruction.
- Session 1: Unlock the Code—Using Decodable Books to Strengthen Phonics Skills
Watch the recording - Session 2: Beyond the Words—Fostering Motivation, Comprehension, and Knowledge
Watch the recording - Session 3: From Sounds to Sentences—Using Decodable Texts to Support Writing
Watch the recording
